The Ward Melville player is the best player on LI.
So here’s the problem, wether you want to choose the girl you mention above or the girl who won, or any of the other dozen girls in the senior class who are all legit players, all very good. But there are no superstars among them. Choose any of them and you could make an argument for them and obviously against them. Many years you have a girl or two who are just a level above, makes this discussion a bit easier. It’s easy to get caught up in the history of the names and the lists and the selections over the years, if it were simply based on performance from this year on the HS field, you may want to start a new list.
WM girl had a tough year. Not a contender
There were others in WM division that beat her. Just because she's going to a top lacrosse program doesn't mean she performed well this year. Of course the school and YJ connection had the biggest part of this pick. Funny if she was so great, she certainly didn't get the job done on the circle especially in the Sachem East game and in OT....
Are you really still talking? This Sachem dad never shuts up. His own wife left the game because he is an embarrassment.
Some parents just can't help themselves.... Always trying to elevate their daughter by knocking and tearing down other players who are considered better than their daughter. While Inside Lacrosse Player Rankings, Under Armour All-American selections and College Coaches opinions are not perfect when a player is recognized by all three as being one of the best I would say the player is legit. Now, when a player is not ranked in the Top 30-40 by Inside Lacrosse, doesn't make UA Senior Game and does not receive any offers from Top 10 Programs, well its safe to say the player is not as good as the ones that do....
IMHO The College Coaches at the Top College Programs are the best evaluators of HS players.
Reply
Quote
