Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
is there an overall rule with Middle Schoolers playing on Varsity? or is it district to district. Are most 8th grade travel kids playing on varsity in suffolk and nassau?

NYS has a waiver that must be completed in order for middle school aged kids to play Hs sports (jv or varsity) you must prove physical maturity and ability In addition each district has there own way of thinking No not all 8 th graders are pulled up.



Only exceptional 8th graders are pulled up. Not only do they have to pass a maturity test, in many districts they also need to guaranteed minimum 50% playing time. This means they need to be as good or better than current starters. Not easy to do in a good district.


personally I think its not good for 8th graders hanging out with seniors. different mentality.. and burn out.. don't know why people push so much to get theirkid on varsity


depends on a few things the kid the district and the parents.

In many of these towns the kids know each other anyways. In other towns, there are related or parents have been friends for years. I think it is worse to be put on JV than varsity. At least on Varsity something is at stake on JV whats the difference records dont count for anything. They are closer in age so behavior differences arent seen as a WOW factor and maybe as a part of growing up.

It all depends on the school district ,strength of program, and sometimes the numbers. In most cases the kids getting pulled up deserve to be pulled up. although many bitter parents will always feel there kid deserved it too. If you have a good coach they will be able to identify the best players and players they feel are going to be a big part of their program whether or not they place them on JV or V. Yes, there are many things to consider if your child is being asked to play at the high school. Whether or not they are mature enough socially is also as important as their maturity physically. The people that come on here and are saying its because of who you know or people being related seem a little jealous to me. Bottom line is enjoy the ride, its only middle schoolers your talking about and they all have a long way to go.