Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
at least

Originally Posted by Anonymous
Catholics would beat any public team by 5 at least. No knock on them, but the poster is way off here.

I heard somewhere that “past performance is no guarantee of future results.” Get your heads out of the past, people. This is the here and now. No longer 2023 or any other year in ancient history, that you think it is.


incredibly well said - unfortunately we will never know - as these teams will not play each other.

True. But do a roster comparison of the 2024’s, and the two public’s come out on top. Fact is, Manhas and GC are probably ahead of the Catholics too.

Not Looking at the IL Div 1 Commitment list, what list are you making up in your mind?
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
at least

Originally Posted by Anonymous
Catholics would beat any public team by 5 at least. No knock on them, but the poster is way off here.

I heard somewhere that “past performance is no guarantee of future results.” Get your heads out of the past, people. This is the here and now. No longer 2023 or any other year in ancient history, that you think it is.


incredibly well said - unfortunately we will never know - as these teams will not play each other.

True. But do a roster comparison of the 2024’s, and the two public’s come out on top. Fact is, Manhas and GC are probably ahead of the Catholics too.

Not Looking at the IL Div 1 Commitment list, what list are you making up in your mind?
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
at least

Originally Posted by Anonymous
Catholics would beat any public team by 5 at least. No knock on them, but the poster is way off here.

I heard somewhere that “past performance is no guarantee of future results.” Get your heads out of the past, people. This is the here and now. No longer 2023 or any other year in ancient history, that you think it is.


incredibly well said - unfortunately we will never know - as these teams will not play each other.

True. But do a roster comparison of the 2024’s, and the two public’s come out on top. Fact is, Manhas and GC are probably ahead of the Catholics too.

Not Looking at the IL Div 1 Commitment list, what list are you making up in your mind?

The roster list. Think about it. The 2 best ‘24 clubs on LI are 91 and Legacy. Tops in the country, in fact. The greatest concentration of players on those teams come from Shoreham and Bayport. I’d say about 6-8 players from each town. That alone almost comprises a starting lineup for each team. With that sort of senior class, both teams should be dominant, to say the least.

In lacrosse you play with 10 starters, the teams you are referring too have been underachieving for there entire HS careers. Once again we will never know because you wont move the Yaphank game to play any of us. I do love the way you stick up for small town USA.