I lived it when my son was asked to do a pg yr while he was being recruited the summer of his jr yr. he was offered a spot in the year younger class. This was his dream school and honestly was thrilled to accept coaches offer. His options were limited and wasn't interested in repeating a Hs year at that point. So he accepted the spot and the next summer, rising sr, he played with the grade he would be playing with after he pgs. He's young for his grade and taking the extra year can only prepare him for for the rigorous schedule of a D1 student athlete. This is one persons experience and we are not interested in anyone's opinion. Just thought we would share.