Why not do a catholic school vs public game in the style of the (Nassau Suffolk game).

I look at it this way. Nassau or Suffolk only plays about 15 kids in that N/S game so combine those 30 boys and make one team, then you say the catholics monopolizes the All-Star event selection process so why not make their political picks another team and have at it.

Do it grade by grade, like N/S game and see who is better; if you think the catholic school teams are all star teams anyway. See what true all-star teams are.