The power rankings system doesn't seem to make sense, as Smithtown West dropped to 4th with West Islip and Smithtown East ahead of them. Smithtown West has a better record than East and same record as West Isliip but has beaten both teams this year. How does that work?
The only non league game you played was against a weak EI team and the fact that half of your games are against the bottom of D1 gives you a lower power ranking. WI is probably higher because they played only the top of the division and two strong non conference games against WB & Hauppauge.