BOTC - US Lacrosse Community Forum Forums MID-ATLANTIC LACROSSE MARYLAND FORUM Girls High School

UA is all about who you know and who knows you. They have good talent, but not the best from top to bottom. I just looked at the AS roster. 2023 is talented, but what happened to the 2022’s, only about 15 players selected and a third are TLC. Must not have been a large 2022 attendee pool.

Good assessment. I like that model.

I would think that most players have a goal of playing in the Under Armour Senior All American game. You may as well just remove your name from consideration if you choose to go play for American Select

Why would any committed 2022 pay over $800 to play in this event when UA is free other than the tryout fee? That's why you don't see many of the top 2022s. Mac is coaching so you have some NDP girls there.

Senior game is still a joke. How does a player not make it on the Senior game but has played in every UA game? How does someone make the Senior game that has not played in the all the UA games? I know - she played in the SPSG championship game, therefore that qualified her? It's all a joke. There are 3 local 22's that are guaranteed a spot on the Senior game, and everyone can name them.

There were 22's that actually got cut from AS

That's absurd. Just because someone chose not to tryout for UA they shouldn't be considered to be one of the top 44 players in the class? Obviously you are talking about the SPSG goalie and I don't think there is anyone that knows the 2021 goalies that wouldn't agree that she is one of the best in the class. She has been incredible in her 2 full years at SPSG and was very good for SW all those years who were one of the best club teams in the class. There is no way she is not one of the top 4 goalies in the 2021 class. And on the flip side how does making UA Underclass every year guarantee you a spot on the senior team? You realize there are hundreds of girls that make UA Underclass every year? Inside Lacrosse and college coaches choose the Senior Team. It is a completely different thing than Underclass. Not everyone that makes Underclass 2 or 3 times can make the Senior Team. You read constantly on here about how the UA Underclass tryouts are flawed and political and then you have people saying that it should be what determines who makes the Senior Team. If you look historically at the UA Senior Teams they do a pretty good job of identifying the top players.

You somewhat made my point. The 2022 roster is weak. There are players on that roster that have not been recruited or committed. In my opinion, the talent did not tryout.

I know kids from across the country that didn’t tryout for UA, because they know it is not fair and open competition. They are arguably some of the best players in the 2022 class. Just because they didn’t tryout doesn’t mean that they won’t get selected for the UA Senior game.

That is correct. Wait till next year to see if the 23 team returns or jumps over to under armour. 23 and below best players chose American select. Fact !

FAX

A few 23s that made AS were at UA tryout FACT!

It depends on the regions which is why it's such a shame that they started this event and scheduled it on the same weekend as UA. It will create 2 watered down events. The SW director is coaching the 2023 AS team so of course they have a lot of the SW girls. The M&D 2024 coach is coaching the 2024 AS team so of course they have a bunch of M&D girls there. In other regions you have the better girls going to UA. The coaches/club directors are determining where girls are trying out because kids think they have a better chance making the team with their coach there.

I know its not East coast competition, but the UA tryouts in Midwest are a complete farce. Unfair is an understatement. The coaches 100% pimp their own kids. Corrigan's ought to be ashamed to have their names associated with this BS! The Midwest girls command team does not have 1 kid from central Ohio which is a girls hotbed. The entire team was made up of Michigan & Minnesota kids. Mich. & Minn. might be the 2 weakest states for girls LAX in the Midwest. Guess where the coaches came from? you guessed it Michigan & Minnesota. Half the final team was probably in the bottom half of the kids who tried out. I don't think there are more than a handful of kids on the team that deserve to be there. Total joke. there were kids in the 44 game that barely touched the ball in the tryouts. Its no surprise why the midwest gets lose every year.

Been saying this for years about CSE. UA is a joke, Senior game included.

Anyone that thinks the senior game is a joke is just mad that their kid wasn't selected. Every kid, boy or girl, has a goal of being selected to play in that game. The senior game and underclass are totally different. The senior game isn't about what club/HS coach chose you in some 4 hour tryout. It's selected by a panel of college coaches and others from Inside Lacrosse based on years of playing. I know every award, list, ranking, etc has to be called a joke on here because it makes people feel better about themselves but these kids need to work hard to get on those teams.

This makes the point. The UA Senior game is selected from a set of criteria. I don’t think that we can argue against the past teams that were selected, and they have been some of the best talent in the country. There is always going to be that bubble player that gets left off of the team, but for the most part they do a good job of selection. CSE has been given great advice in the past on selecting evaluators and coaches from other states with no club affiliation, but they choose to ignore great advice. My daughter made the UA underclass team twice, but she chose not to tryout the last two years because of the partiality. She knew that there were players on her past UA team that were chosen because of who they knew, and she was very opposed to this practice.

If a Redshirt makes the team, we should all protest to CSE. No way any player from that team is a top player

100%^
There’s a reason why Corrigan is tweeting about AS, makes me think their tryout numbers decreased by a lot for him to tweet about it!

The 2020 UA 2022 call backs were pretty much BMS players. Guess who was the coach: BM.

You somewhat made my point. The 2022 roster is weak. There are players on that roster that have not been recruited or committed. In my opinion, the talent did not tryout.[/quote]

That is correct. Wait till next year to see if the 23 team returns or jumps over to under armour. 23 and below best players chose American select. Fact ![/quote]

A few 23s that made AS were at UA tryout FACT![/quote]

Those 23s be flexing’. Fishing for accolades. They wouldn’t be on the AS rosters unless they paid the money.
It’s not a great year for the 23’s to be trying out for Highlight. There are some real beasts on the 22’s.

And BM is coaching American Select this year and those BMS girls are there. So as much as they want to say AS is different it’s the same thing except it costs $700 more

Agree. BM is a TLC coach and director of the TLC middle school program. So that’s why we see five TLC players on AS 2022. AS selection is no better than UA, it just cost more.

I think you are wrong. Coaches never told girls where to go. Maybe by their presence influenced their decision to try. Also coaches had no input on teams. And most of the 23 sw made the UA team with an NDP coach and 2 mnd coaches that didn’t coach 23 age group. Try again with another excuse.

That is not true and how can you assert this fabrication. A coach advised my daughter to tryout for the AS team. Coaches do advise kids where to go.

If there was any question on the goal of American Select, the fact that they are having 2 teams at each age group on Long Island should answer them. It's a total money grab. 44 girls per age? That's not exactly just the elite.

Seriously?

Yes, check the AS website and for LI when it shows the coaches it shows 1 2022 team and then 2 teams at 2022, 2023 and 2024. I guess if you can swindle and extra almost $40k ($595 x 22 girls x 3 teams) why wouldn't you when the whole reason for starting the event was to make money to begin with. They took the UA model which did not make a lot of money for CSE and realized that it could be a goldmine if they scheduled it the same week and set the tryouts before UAs. Saying it would be run differently and then seeing that almost all the coaches were prior UA coaches should have been a clue. Not to mention that it is being run by the person that used to run UA Underclass tryouts. A sucker is born every minute and when it comes to lacrosse parents that are desperate for little Susie to have accolades it's probably more like every 30 seconds.

Ouch, but true.

Correct on all accounts... but no 2022 team.. no one showed up to tryout

I guess the MD parents are a bit more thirsty to put something on their daughter's resume. It certainly won't help the 2022s make the Senior UA team if they chose to play AS instead of trying out for UA. But with LI not having a 2022 team the MD team should have a pretty easy tournament.

The 2022 MD team is weak. Look at the roster.

Such a ridiculous comment

23 md girls on highlight team. How many will make the final 44 next year ? Not all 23 !!

Of course not, but do you think if there is a comparison between 2 girls and one went to AS and the other tried out for and played on UA CSE is going to choose the girl that played on the AS team instead of taking a chance and waiting for UA tryouts that just seems shortsighted.

If the best of the best play for UA, why are a lot of the 22’s selected not all committed? If your the best of the best, wouldn’t you have committed by now? The word “best” is so over rated

I am looking at the AS 2022 roster. No one on that roster would make the UA team. Some are B team players that went to TLC, and some are just not impressive.

That is what others have communicated. UA underclass selections are typically not the best of the best, but selected because of who they know. The UA Senior team is typically the best of the best, with some that may have been left off the roster.

But yet some have been on the UA team in the past…so clearly you don’t know what you are talking about

I'm pretty sure that every 2022 on the Baltimore and LI UA team will be committed. Obviously from other regions you aren't always going to have everyone committed at this point. Their called hotbeds for a reason and Baltimore/LI/CONNY/NY/Philly/DC usually dominate the event.