Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Since 2005, that is as far back as a quick search revealed. Here are the numbers.

In the past 9 seasons here are all of the teams that have been able to compete in the Suffolk "A" County Finals.

West Islip - 8 times

Ward Melville - 8 times

Smithtown West - 2 times

If the league was competitive some other teams would be in the mix.


You keep stating past accomplishments. We know!

You don't attempt to address the present!

West Islip and WM are not what they were in the past.

There are other very good team this year!

Why can't you admit this, stats are there to support!


It is not possible that West Islip is not what they were in the past.

I have heard about their winning formula many times. "Craig and company win because they keep the boys together in the summer". Has something changed in West Islip? Have the HS players not been playing together in the summer the past couple of years?

As for the other debate, I would agree that Smithtown West is very good this year. Ward Melville also looks strong. Can any other teams in Suffolk A compete against GC, Manhasset, SA, Chaminade, Massapequa? I don't know, Maybe NP.

Can't agree with you on the league being strong. A few strong teams but like all the other leagues on Long Island not deep. I think they should make a "power conference".