BOTC - US Lacrosse Community Forum Forums NORTHEAST LACROSSE BOTC MAIN FORUM (LI, CT, WC) Long Island Top Guns Lacrosse

Listen dbag - if you want to start calling out kids go ahead and we'll have a long conversation. Mistakes were made in both games Saturday by many/all the girls. The first game was lost in the second half when some of the nonstarters didn't play. If you're going to call out kids show your name and don't be gutless.

What's your name? Or do you just go by "Tough Guy?"

That's been SS team since inception, as soon as it became apparent that they couldn't compete she bailed out

No one called out kids, it is just reality in the money making world of girls lacrosse. To me a team should be no more than 22 players. 6 or 7 more girls make it impossible to get even playing time, especially when you are at a championship format tournament. There is not enough talent in an organization for a supposed "A" team to have that many players on their roster.

Let's be honest, if it is a championship format the organization wants to win the tournament. This is good for the program because they can boast about their success thus getting more players to sign up for future years.

On the other side of the equation it was a showcase as well with college coaches so it is understandable that the uncommitted girls want to play and be seen. With
the early commits they need to change the travel landscape. If there are 5 - 6 tournaments in the summer have half of them where everyone plays and have the other half tournaments for uncommitted girls, and this goes for every club so that there are not lopsided games. Also, you should never have a showcase as part of a championship format.

It appears the "starters" didn't do too well. Maybe the "starters" shouldn't be.

Hmmm and guess who should be starting

This bickering is so surprising. TG's are has beens. Long time coming, well not really. Feel so bad for all of you really my heart hurts.

I'll guess, is it the non-starters?

Another rough weekend for 2018. Even with BS on both sidelines, it didn't make a difference. Losing to teams they should be beating.

Its a showcase...you complain when they play to win and you complain when they play whole team and lose

It's not about wins and losses at a showcase.

Really, so shocking! Heard they did great. Especially the starters.

Showcase, showcase, showcase. The goal is to showcase girls to the college coaches. I've been on the sidelines with the coaches...they don't care about the score nor do they know the score. They are there to watch the girls that have contacted them or the girls they are recruiting. I wish they wouldn't even keep the score cards. Relax.

Please don't tell them to relax.... The coaches are watching them too. It gives all the other girls a better shot when they scratch the daughters of the loudmouth parents off their list!

So I guess him running isolation plays for the same girls over and over again helps everyone get recruited? I don't think so

U-15 tournament is underway in Indy.. TG Black tied Integrity 8-8 in first pool game

How is your black team doing?

Won their pool

In answer to your question, how did TG Black do at the U15, they were 5-1-1 and came in 3rd. Yj in 1st, Liberty, 2nd.

Total waste of time and money

I think TG 23's better than YJ's 23. Saw them both play but when will they go head to head?

Very true but the better TG girls will move to YJ and they will be the dominate team in a few years. Look back and history will repeat itself. TG does do a better job of developing talent but CR does a better job of plucking g the best.

Can anyone tell me the deadline TG uses for acceptance in their program? Is it before YJ's? If so, do they have a history of making exceptions if someone tried out for YJ also and didn't like their YJ placement?

Anyone

Try outs are August 27 and 28 depending on the age group. Usually find out first week in September if you made a team. Girls have shown up in the past during the winter from other teams if there were open spots on teams. Doesn't matter which club they come from.

Very true but the better TG girls will move to YJ and they will be the dominate team in a few years. Look back and history will repeat itself. TG does do a better job of developing talent but CR does a better job of plucking g the best.

TG 2023 beat YJ 2023 this year. But sadly the above poster is probably correct the better TG girls will end up moving to YJ.

To say the TG develops players better than YJ is just a false statement.... read a few post above about how B.S. attempts at running a game, to S.S. overseeing teams...

don't count on that happening.....already hearing of YJ blue kids looking elsewhere.

What size roster do TG teams typically have?

Look on their site-- they are big rosters. Big rosters are going to be the case for any team of note, but I wonder about the truth of their playing time philosophy. You'll never get the truth of that here since every one's full of it (for an against).

My youngin' is gonna tryout this fall but I wish I watched them a little on the sidelines this year to see how girls are given playing time.

Depends on the age group. 2018 had the two biggest rosters because 3 teams were combined into 2 when a ton of girls left. Most teams have 22-24 girls.

I can only comment on the 2018 purple team. The roster was too big. Only had 4 girls that played defense and they never came off the field. Almost 3 full lines for attack and midfield. Girls only got 1 shift per half. Coaches rarely subbed on the fly. Many parents were upset about the playing time to the point they called BS to complain. He coached the very next tournament to see first hand and still was unable to figure it out. 6 girls missing at the hofstra tournament was the only reason the playing time went up.

I have had kids on both YJ and TG, the A teams were capped at 24, but the B, C, D whatever have had up 28-29 kids on the team different years. 24 players is really the max as its 2 full teams ( If the team is properly constructed of 8 defense, 6 middies, 8 attack and 2 goalies)
A few less is better, 18-20 dedicated players who all show-up is ideal.
some clubs post rosters, take a look and count for yourself

Look on their site-- they are big rosters. Big rosters are going to be the case for any team of note, but I wonder about the truth of their playing time philosophy. You'll never get the truth of that here since every one's full of it (for an against).

My youngin' is gonna tryout this fall but I wish I watched them a little on the sidelines this year to see how girls are given playing time.

YJ 2023 A team has 26 on the roster and plenty of complaints about playing time

If you make a team you have a couple of weeks to send in your $500 non refundable deposit. If your daughter chooses to tryout for another program and accept a spot there then you forfeit yor $500.

my daughters team ran 6 attack, 6 middies, 6 defenders & 2 goalies

Lucky you. My daughters team ran 11 attack, 8 middies, 4 defense and 2 goalies. Season was a total waste.

Here's my thought on rosters size. Carry too many people complain. Carry too few and you screw yourself. Anything under 21-22 is no good. My daughter had 19 and at 2 tournaments we had no subs. People blow off tournaments for other sports, vacation, Aunt Gertrude's birthday party whatever. I can't understand how you spend all this money and don't care. And screw the other girls in the process because they are dying in 90 degree heat!

Because Aunt Gertrude turns 90 only once and she may not be here next year. In my book, family first!