BOTC - US Lacrosse Community Forum Forums NORTHEAST LACROSSE BOTC MAIN FORUM (LI, CT, WC) CHAMINADE Lacrosse. Stories and news.

yeah, notice how he was a good player, was the test relevant to the sport, no it wasnt. As for the test they squashed it the next year (or year after that) so the rules for the physical test were a crock and found to be such and done away with.

what ever happened to that player and coach?

So if the season doesnt count is it conceivable to think the players get their year of eligibility back?

Although governed by different bodies, they follow NFHS rules as many schools across the country do

Then why didn't they play in the championship game? Because they brought varsity players back to JV team for playoffs

You cannot possibly be this stupid.

You speak with such conviction about a scenario in which you have no clue about the rules. Catholic League Basketball rules state that players can only play in one playoff (Varsity or JV). JV players may go up and down during the season for a set number of games before they must stay up on Varsity. None of the JV players were near that number of games. The player you speak of was a Freshman, who was up for a few non league games, and was sent back to the JV to play in their playoffs. The Sophomore who came up, stayed on Varsity for the playoffs. Both could have played the JV Championship, but one stayed with the Varsity.

So.... kid who caused the uproar at St. A was sabotaged by the Mom of the backup LSM. Mommy was pissed her son wasn't starting, so she blew the whistle. Shame on the selfish [lacrosse]!

Thanks HRC voter, hate the whistle blower, not the offender. Jackass

So it's the whistle blowers fault? Yes, that's exactly what's wrong with society today. Nobody wants to be held accountable for their own actions.

Season counted as the games were played. They just forfeited all of them.

Test is meant to verify physical maturity. Test still exists for all sports if a middle school player is pulled up to JV or Varsity.

Thanks mom for ruining the last game for the Seniors. Your son didn't play because he sucks, you should have stayed public. Now everyone hates you and him.

Hahahaha, glad your sons season got ruined you jerk. I hope you're both crying your eyes out, feel soooo good he missed his last game!

<Poster completely misses the point AND makes the quoted poster's point for him - classic!.

Has to be a HS writing that post and missing the point completely. Sad.

Are you that f'n stupid to say that. This isnt about accoubtability.

In general, I am okay with whistle blowers. But when the motive is as rotten as the situation you have to think twice. The question has to be, If her kid was playing would she have made a stink.

Whistle blowing for the sake of justice and Right i have no problem with... I have an issue when it is an issue of self-promotion

The "test" does not exist, another one was put in its place. Not the same process less vigorous. Has even less to do with any sport. As well, get rid of the 3 days of tryouts for the underclassmen; If they cant take the first month let them be allowed to drop back to MS ball.

If violation of the rules with clearly defined penalties for violation are a crock, then yes it was a crock also. Eighth grader brought up to play varsity but the player didn't meet some of the physical requirements to play up.[/quote]

yeah, notice how he was a good player, was the test relevant to the sport, no it wasnt. As for the test they squashed it the next year (or year after that) so the rules for the physical test were a crock and found to be such and done away with.

what ever happened to that player and coach?
[/quote]

Test is meant to verify physical maturity. Test still exists for all sports if a middle school player is pulled up to JV or Varsity.[/quote]

The "test" does not exist, another one was put in its place. Not the same process less vigorous. Has even less to do with any sport. As well, get rid of the 3 days of tryouts for the underclassmen; If they cant take the first month let them be allowed to drop back to MS ball.


[/quote]
So a test does exist if I am understanding your gibberish.

It's all about accountability! Who gives a sh$t what the motive it? St A violated the rules. End of story

Mommy threw out the baby with the bathwater.

Time to find another school for little Johnny alter boy.

I don't claim that the Mid Atlantic folks are any smarter than our Long Island friends but would it not make sense that the semi final team that lost to St. Ants would be declared the winner since they have to forfeit the win. Wouldn't it make sense for that team to play Chaminade for the title? What am I missing. (please don't correct any grammar) Just answer what seems to be an easy question from the outside.

Whistle blower in this case (apparently) was a malcontent... How is it, that you can't find anyone from; Coaches, Players, parents, fans, alumni, faculty, administration, on neither Anthony's nor Chaminade, that was in favor of canceling Championship game, but game was still cancelled?

Opinion Question, will Chaminade's Varsity team be stronger, weaker, or same next year?

Dear Hillary, CHSAA felt it was right to cancel game. Result: cancelled! Please don't speak for everyone you ignorant jackass. You must be a St. A guy, proper grammar is either, not neither, you moron .

There is no semi-final team that lost to St. Anthony's. Chaminade and St. Anthony's are the only two AAA Catholic school teams in the state. They play each other for the "championship" every year.

You hate the whistle blowing mother because her son wasn't getting the playingtime her son would've gotten if not for the cheating family? So she should have shut up and let her son get screwed? You people have a twisted moral compass

Hint: Not one of those people had any authority to be involved in a decision based upon established rules that clearly laid out the resulting penalties.

Easy Answer to your "Easy Question": While your alternative solution might be reasonable, it is an alternative, IE, NOT the solution clearly laid in the established league's rules to deal with specific situation at hand. It is both surprising and sad how the concept of adhering to rules is foreign to so many.[u][/u]

Parents doing all that jockeying around, reclassing, changing schools multiple times...for what?

a trip to Arcadia

destruction of two teams seasons

winning their son the "pariah of the year" award

priceless

Nice way to be remembered.......The kid who's helicopter mom destroyed the lacrosse season.......loser.

In this situation the winner of the AA should have been asked to play Chaminade for a unified championship this year, not fear to any of the Seniors on both side but especially Chaminade seniors. They are entitled to play a last game in the colors of their school

"entitled" - If that word doesn't say so much about the problems we face with society today, then I don't know what does . . .!

Can this subject die already?? Boo hoo....the seniors didn't get to play their last game.

Yes they did, they just didn't know it was their last game at the time. Move on!

First, there is a limit to the number of games a team can play in a season. Second, they did play a last game it just happened it wasn't for the AAA "championship".

How was Chaminade's season destroyed?

Boo hoo! Really.? You obviously have. I idea what playing at SA or Chaminde is like and what that last game means to these great kids. People in the outside have NO clue but claim to know everything

The Chaminade senior boys are already over it. You should be too by now.

If you went to either of these schools you should demand a full refund, you write like a third grader. And NO ONE cares but you, waaaaa, stomp feet and ball up little fists, our season got cut short.

And you act like a third grader