First of all, it's not a contest. It doesn't matter who goes where, as long as the player and parents are happy with the destination. Second, I bet if you look at ANY club team's website and look at the alumni they would ALL look the same...D1, D2, D3.
Example 1:

Integrity: Small club.
Caitlin Blanche, Navy
Katie Cavanaugh, Belmont Abbey
Lexi Clark, Shenandoah
Hannah Coakley, Rollins College
Kali Ferguson, Mount Olive
Sarah Gillogly, Monmouth University
Skylar Grady, UMBC
Carson Gregg, University of Denver
Angelica Jensen, Hofstra
Jackie Kaderabek, Mount Olive
Mckensey Lavin, Shenandoah
Gina Openshaw, Brown University (Field Hockey)
Emily Nutter, Monmouth University
Lucy Sullivan, Salisbury
Madeline Szanyi, Hofstra University

Example 2:
Md United: Medium large club.
Payton Beach - Virginia Tech
Julianna Brown - George Mason
Sydney Davis - St. Francis
Abby Dengler - Grand Valley State
Meredith Dillon - Costal Carolina
Brianna Harris - Florida
Kayla Harris - US Naval Academy
Brittany Jacobs - Campbell
Chelsea Kibler - U Penn
Kayla Koch - Presbyterian College
Maddie McDaniel - James Madison
Laura Milleker - Denver
Abigail O’Neal - Grand Valley State
Emma Schwartz - George Mason
Skylar Simmers - Grand Valley State
Kasey Stevens - Jacksonville
Taylor Sullivan - San Diego State
Makenzie Aponte - Long Island U
Kendall Bannan - Salisbury
Molly Barkman - Longwood
Abby Bernhardt - Mary Washington
Jordan Conley - [lacrosse]
Brooke Dooley - Delaware
Emily D’Orsaneo - Loch Haven
Madeline Gonzalez - Central Michigan
Emma Hamilton - Central Michigan
Maddie La Clair - Towson
Brooke Malamphy - La Salle
Stephanie Miller - Monmouth
Kelly Sheilds - IUP
Abigail Single - Salisbury
Alexandra Wilder - Rollins University

I just don't see any real difference here. The destination of all the players on all the clubs runs the gamut in many parameters.